A lieutenant with the San Francisco Fire Department is currently under investigation following comments he made on social media that appeared to support a federal immigration operation in Oakland. Lt. David Waters, who has served in the department for over a decade, reacted to a news story concerning a November 19 incident, where an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) vehicle was involved in a high-speed chase that damaged a pregnant woman’s car. Waters’s comment included a GIF featuring the phrase “Gotta catch ‘em all!” referencing a popular children’s franchise, which many interpreted as a call for increased deportations.
The incident referenced by Waters involved ICE agents pursuing a suspect who had reportedly dropped off a child at an elementary school. During the pursuit, the vehicle collided with the woman’s car, although she was unharmed. Following Waters’ initial comment on a post from SFGate, a user criticized his remarks, suggesting that they reflected racist sentiments. In response, Waters defended his position, questioning how wanting to deport individuals could be deemed racist.
As the controversy grew, Waters deleted his social media posts, and his Instagram profile was removed. His LinkedIn account, previously identifying him as a lieutenant, now lists him as a landscape photographer. According to data from Transparent California, Waters’ total compensation in his most recent year was approximately $319,625.98, which included both salary and benefits.
The San Francisco Fire Department has stated they take the matter seriously. Lt. Mariano Elias emphasized in a public statement that the comments made by Waters do not align with the department’s values. “We value diversity, equity, and inclusion, and we do not tolerate behavior that promotes hate or discrimination,” Elias said. He confirmed that the department would conduct a thorough investigation and take appropriate actions, which may include disciplinary measures.
Waters has not publicly responded to requests for comment regarding the incident. The investigation continues as the fire department seeks to uphold its commitment to serve all members of the community, irrespective of background or immigration status.
This situation highlights a growing tension surrounding immigration enforcement in the United States, particularly in cities like San Francisco that prioritize inclusivity and community service. As the investigation unfolds, the department aims to reaffirm its dedication to these principles while addressing the actions of its personnel.
