URGENT UPDATE: Nimmo United Methodist Church in Virginia Beach is pushing to be removed from the historic district that bears its name, citing overwhelming repair costs. The Planning Commission met on Wednesday to discuss the church’s request, which, if granted, would dismantle the entire Nimmo Church Historical and Cultural District.
This surprising move has sparked debate, as church representatives were absent during the crucial meeting. The church’s appeal stems from exorbitant material and labor costs linked to necessary repairs and improvements, according to city officials. A decision on the matter has been deferred until January 14, with commissioners expressing concerns about the potential implications for historic preservation across the city.
“It’s an important issue affecting our consideration of this district and other districts throughout the city,” stated Commissioner Bryan Plumlee. The church, recognized as the oldest Methodist church in continuous use in the United States, faces significant hurdles due to the stringent review processes of the Historic Review Board.
Officials report that both the Historic Review Board and the Historic Preservation Commission have already denied the church’s request, indicating they fear it could set a damaging precedent for other historic sites. The church has not submitted any recent applications for maintenance or changes, raising questions about the specific repairs needed.
Virginia Beach currently protects 16 historical and cultural districts, preserving structures that date back to the Colonial era. The Nimmo district was established in 1980 and is located near the intersection of General Booth Boulevard and Princess Anne Road, including a recently built Royal Farms convenience store.
The board evaluates development proposals for compatibility with the district’s design and materials, and owners must secure a “certificate of appropriateness” for any alterations. Past applications have included a request from a homeowners association to install a gate and several proposals for new construction. Notably, the board recently rejected a homebuilder’s attempt to install a vinyl fence in another district.
Councilwoman Barbara Henley has voiced her awareness of the church’s plight, highlighting that the review board’s rigorous standards may be financially burdensome. “Being in the (historic and cultural) district, they’re just required to meet the highest standard of historic preservation,” she remarked, noting that the costs can become prohibitive.
The church’s origins date back to 1791, with its steeple added in 1893—both key elements of its historical significance. During the Civil War, the church served as a hospital for Union forces. Despite its rich history, the path forward remains uncertain as local officials seek to balance preservation with the church’s financial realities.
As the Planning Commission prepares for their next meeting on January 14, community members and preservationists alike will be watching closely. The outcome could reshape the future of not only Nimmo United Methodist Church but also other historic districts in Virginia Beach.
Stay tuned for updates on this developing story as the situation unfolds.
