URGENT UPDATE: Developers behind the controversial affordable housing project at the Elizabeth Street Garden in Nolita have just filed a lawsuit against Mayor Eric Adams. The legal action, initiated on Wednesday, claims the mayor unlawfully designated the site as city parkland to block construction of a 123-unit residential building intended for low-income seniors.
The lawsuit argues that Adams’ declaration, made following the recent general election, constitutes “an extraordinary act of executive overreach.” Haven Green, the development group, insists that parkland designation must undergo the city’s land-use process, requiring approval from the City Council. They assert that the project has undergone an exhaustive public review and adheres to lawful governmental decisions made over the past decade.
In a surprising turnaround, the Adams administration had initially planned to evict the garden to allow for the housing project. However, in June, officials announced a deal to construct other affordable housing units in nearby locations, shifting course dramatically. The situation escalated when Adams designated the garden as parkland, effectively halting any construction efforts.
Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani, who previously supported the eviction of the garden, now warns that major construction on parkland would require state legislative approval, making it “nearly impossible” to move forward with Haven Green’s plans. His administration has expressed a willingness to collaborate with the garden’s operators to ensure the space is preserved.
The Elizabeth Street Garden’s supporters highlight the site’s “environmental, cultural, and artistic significance,” arguing that it is one of the last green spaces in the neighborhood. In a statement, the garden’s operators criticized Haven Green’s lawsuit as a “misguided attempt” to overturn the city’s protective action.
The ongoing dispute has ignited tension between housing advocates and local residents, with many arguing for the preservation of the garden. In June, First Deputy Mayor Randy Mastro stated that a deal was in place to advance over 600 units of affordable housing in surrounding areas, with plans for ground-breaking by the end of this year.
As the legal battle unfolds, the stakes are high for both sides. The outcome will not only affect the future of the Elizabeth Street Garden but also the broader conversation about affordable housing in New York City.
Stay tuned for further developments as this story continues to evolve.
