The recent episode of *Yellowstone*, titled ‘Give The World Away’, has drawn significant criticism for its apparent prioritization of creator Taylor Sheridan and his character, Travis Wheatley, over the established story arcs and main characters of the series. This backlash comes despite the show’s remarkable success since its premiere in 2018, where it has consistently dominated cable ratings and streaming charts.
The episode, which is part of *Yellowstone*’s fifth season, received a rating of 7.1 on IMDb. This score is notably lower than the show’s overall average of 8.6 and well below some of its most acclaimed episodes, which have achieved ratings as high as 9.2. Viewers have expressed dissatisfaction, claiming that the episode serves more as a showcase for Sheridan than as a continuation of the main narrative.
Critics have pointed to the heavy emphasis on Wheatley, who has appeared intermittently throughout the series as an acquaintance of John Dutton. In this episode, Wheatley’s role is expanded, leading many to feel that the storytelling is compromised. Instead of focusing on pivotal plotlines, such as the ongoing feud between Beth and Jamie Dutton or the future of the Dutton ranch, the episode diverts attention to Wheatley and his interactions, which some viewers found contrived.
One particularly controversial scene features Wheatley engaging in a game of strip poker with three women, including his girlfriend, played by model Bella Hadid. Critics argue that such moments detract from the series’ established tone and narrative depth, instead feeling like a vehicle for Sheridan to promote his own presence on screen.
The timing of this narrative shift is viewed as especially inappropriate, occurring just before the series finale. Fans expected the penultimate episode to address lingering conflicts but were instead met with a focus on a character who has not been central to the storyline. This has led to disappointment among loyal viewers who feel shortchanged by the diversion.
The negative reception of ‘Give The World Away’ highlights the potential pitfalls when a creator takes on a prominent acting role within their own project. While Sheridan is undeniably talented behind the camera, this episode raises questions about the effectiveness of his dual role as writer and actor in *Yellowstone*.
Despite this setback, Sheridan remains a significant figure in contemporary television. His other projects, such as Landman and Tulsa King, continue to attract strong audiences, showcasing his ability to connect with viewers. Additionally, Sheridan is expanding the *Yellowstone* universe with upcoming projects like Y: Marshals and a series centered on Beth and Rip, ensuring that fans have more content to look forward to.
In a notable recent development, Sheridan signed a lucrative deal with Universal, effectively ending his association with Paramount. This move signifies a new chapter in his career, as he prepares to co-write a major film project based on Call of Duty prior to his departure from Paramount in 2028. As Sheridan continues to shape the landscape of television and film, many hope he will focus on his strengths in writing and producing rather than taking on leading roles that may detract from the narratives he has built.
The reaction to this episode serves as a reminder of the delicate balance that creators must maintain when stepping in front of the camera. Fans of *Yellowstone* remain hopeful for a return to the series’ core themes and character developments in future episodes.
