The season 3 finale of the Hulu series The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, released on November 13, 2024, has stirred fresh intrigue with hints of a potential rekindled romance between star Taylor Frankie Paul and Chase McWhorter. Their recent meeting, which included an apology from Chase for past actions, has raised questions about their relationship following a scandal involving soft swinging that initially caused significant drama among their social circles.
During the finale, Chase and Taylor shared a lunch where they reflected on their history and even joked about a possible kiss. This interaction contrasts sharply with their previous tensions, which stemmed from a complex web of romantic entanglements. Prior to the show’s premiere in September 2024, Taylor found herself embroiled in controversy due to her involvement in a “soft swinging” incident while still married to Tate Paul. This scandal involved her interactions with various couples, including Chase and his then-wife Miranda McWhorter.
In season 2, Taylor explained the circumstances surrounding the scandal, stating, “Her husband was the one [who] had feelings for me. That’s where the story gets confusing.” She emphasized that she never intended to betray Miranda, whom she described as a close friend. Taylor further elaborated on the situation, mentioning that the relationships involved were far more complicated than they appeared, including shared intimate experiences during weekends with other couples.
After the fallout from the scandal, Taylor and Tate ended their marriage, and she subsequently began dating Dakota Mortensen, her first boyfriend following her divorce. The couple welcomed their son, Ever, in 2024, but their relationship ended amid rumors of infidelity involving Dakota. Chase also moved on after his marriage to Miranda ended in 2024, stating, “I think we both realized that we’d gotten married a little prematurely.” Despite their divorce, he noted that they maintained a cordial relationship for the sake of their children.
Chase recounted how the soft-swinging activities began during the COVID-19 pandemic, describing a setting where couples would gather and engage in games while drinking alcohol. He expressed that the portrayal of events surrounding the scandal was misrepresented, clarifying, “It was never predetermined that we were going to be doing, like, swinging.”
With the stage set for a possible reunion, Chase revealed during the finale that he had recently broken up with his girlfriend, Kate Racker. Their lunch quickly turned into a light-hearted discussion about their past feelings, with Chase admitting, “Honestly, Taylor, I always thought you were one of the coolest people ever.” Taylor, who identified as a “very flirty person,” acknowledged the chemistry that remained between them. The episode concluded with Chase playfully suggesting they kiss for “old times’ sake,” leaving viewers wondering about the future of their relationship.
Since the filming of the season, Taylor has been cast as the lead in an upcoming season of The Bachelorette, indicating that she may not pursue a renewed romance with Chase.
As the narrative around these relationships continues to unfold, the dynamic between Taylor and Chase remains a focal point for fans and followers of the show. The evolving nature of their interactions, combined with the personal and public challenges they face, paints a complex picture of love, friendship, and the repercussions of their past decisions.
