Netflix’s highly anticipated release of The Witcher Season 4 has generated significant disappointment among fans, resulting in a low 18% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes. The season debuted on October 26, 2023, marking a notable shift in the series with Liam Hemsworth stepping into the role of Geralt of Rivia, previously played by Henry Cavill. This transition came with mixed reactions, further complicated by the show’s adaptation of Andrzej Sapkowski‘s original works.
Many fans took to social media to express their dissatisfaction, with some characterizing the new season as a “parody” of the source material. The series, which follows Geralt’s adventures in a perilous world filled with monsters, has long been celebrated for its rich storytelling, but this latest installment has left viewers feeling shortchanged. The opening featured a brief voice-over of Cavill’s Geralt before transitioning to Hemsworth’s portrayal, which some fans found jarring.
Critics have echoed these sentiments, noting that the narrative appears rushed, failing to capture the depth of Sapkowski’s universe. One reviewer remarked, “While his predecessor invested Geralt with a gruff likability, Geralt II is less ‘valorous man-mountain grappling with responsibilities beyond our ken’ and more ‘bollard in a wig.'” This comparison underlines the challenges Hemsworth faces in filling Cavill’s shoes, with some viewers still adjusting to the change.
Online discussions have also highlighted the circumstances surrounding Cavill’s departure. Reports suggest he left the series due to creative differences with the writing team over authenticity to the books. Despite some positive feedback on Hemsworth’s performance, a significant portion of the audience remains unconvinced.
The show’s pacing has also drawn criticism. With key plot developments presented in a rapid-fire montage, many feel the storytelling lacks the nuance and exploration expected from such a beloved franchise. Fans had hoped for a deeper dive into Geralt’s relationships with characters like Yennefer and Ciri, but these moments were insufficiently fleshed out.
Looking ahead, The Witcher is set to conclude with Season 5, which has already been filmed back-to-back with the current season. This final chapter is anticipated for release in late 2024. In addition to the main series, Netflix has expanded the Witcher universe with a spinoff titled The Rats: A Witcher Tale, along with other related projects such as The Witcher: Blood Origin and The Witcher: Nightmare of the Wolf. These initiatives indicate Netflix’s commitment to the franchise, even as the reception of Season 4 casts a shadow over its future.
As fans continue to voice their opinions, the future of The Witcher remains uncertain, with high expectations for the concluding season to redeem the series and honor the legacy of its source material.
