A divisive horror film from 2025, initially criticized and labeled a box office disappointment, is now gaining traction on the streaming platform Peacock. The movie, which explores themes of toxic masculinity and the pursuit of greatness within the realm of American football, offers unique visuals and thought-provoking ideas that may deserve a second look from audiences.
Films often receive mixed reactions upon their theatrical release, but this particular title stands out. It has become increasingly common for movies that struggle in cinemas to experience a resurgence on streaming platforms, where viewers have the flexibility to watch from home. While platforms like Netflix have historically been the go-to for underperforming films, others, including Peacock, Hulu, and HBO Max, are emerging as popular destinations for viewers seeking films they might have initially overlooked.
The film in question, directed by Justin Tipping, failed to resonate with mainstream audiences, earning just $27.8 million worldwide against a production budget of $27 million. The promotional strategy may have played a role in this outcome. Trailers, while visually impressive, were deemed unconventional and misleading. Many viewers mistakenly believed acclaimed filmmaker Jordan Peele directed the film due to heavy promotion of his name, which led to confusion and disappointment among those expecting a similar style.
Critical reception was similarly harsh, with a mere 30% rating on Rotten Tomatoes and a 57% audience score on the Popcornmeter. Critics acknowledged the film’s ambitious themes and stylish visuals but agreed that it struggled to deliver on its narrative potential. Audience feedback mirrored these sentiments, recognizing the strong symbolism and compelling ideas while ultimately finding the execution lacking.
The film centers on Cam Cade, portrayed by Tyriq Withers, a young football player who has the chance to learn from his idol, quarterback Isaiah White, played by Marlon Wayans. Many critics consider this role one of Wayans’ best performances. The film attempts to tackle significant issues such as toxic masculinity and the violent nature of sports, but it faces challenges in balancing its ambitious thematic material.
In response to the negative reviews, Marlon Wayans expressed respect for critics while also asserting that the film was innovative and perhaps ahead of its time. He emphasized that it explores the true definition of greatness and the lengths individuals will go to achieve it. Despite its shortcomings, the film’s ambition and striking visuals make it a noteworthy addition to the horror genre, particularly for those who appreciate films that challenge conventional narratives and engage with social issues.
Now available on Peacock, this horror film presents an opportunity for reevaluation. The shift to streaming platforms allows for niche films or those that initially struggled to find their audience a second chance. As viewers seek content that resonates with them, this film’s unique themes and provocative ideas may finally reach an appreciative audience.
Ultimately, the film’s journey from box office flop to streaming success reflects a changing landscape in how audiences consume media. As more films are reexamined in the light of their themes and execution, this horror film may well find the recognition it initially lacked.
